If you’re mapping out the best stone crab restaurants on Marco Island, circle mid‑October through May 1. That’s Florida’s official season, with harvest closing after May 1. The fishery is unusual—and sustainable—because harvesters take the legal‑size claws and return the live crab to the water.

Reviewer Tip: Stone crab runs sell out daily. Go early or ask the host if claws were fresh cracked today.

Before You Go: Your 5‑Minute Prep

Season opens Oct. 15 and ends May 1; minimum legal claw size is 2 7/8 inches. Traps must have escape rings to reduce bycatch—part of the stewardship locals care about. Staying near marinas makes dock‑and‑dine simple—browse the Lodging guide. For pre‑dinner beach time and easy access paths, see the Marco Island beaches guide.

---

The Best Stone Crab Restaurants on Marco — (two local classics)

Snook Inn

Sits right on the Marco River with waterside dining and a lively chickee bar—come by boat or by car and time it for sunset.

CJ’s on the Bay

Anchors the Esplanade on Smokehouse Bay with inside dining, a large outdoor gazebo bar, and public dockage—handy for boaters. Reservations are recommended. CJ’s On The Bay

Want more options? Start with our curated Dining guide to explore the island’s seafood‑forward spots during season.

---

How to order (and what to pair)

Ask for pre‑cracked, chilled claws on ice with mustard sauce—the Florida classic. A great plate looks tidy, with sweet meat that releases cleanly. Regulations focus on claw size and sustainable harvest so you can order with confidence.

Size up by appetite: mediums for sharing; larger sizes for fewer, meatier bites. Pair with a crisp white or brut bubbles and simple sides like slaw or a green salad.

---

A local’s mini itinerary (AM → PM) + practicalities

Morning — Walk the shoreline and do a little shelling; our Things to do page has boat tours if you want to get on the water before lunch.

Late afternoon — Check Tides & sunsets and aim for golden‑hour seating at stone crab restaurants Marco Island like Snook Inn or CJ’s on the Bay.

Evening — Settle into a waterfront table, start with a shared plate of claws, and linger for the sky show. If plans shift, peek at the Events calendar and pivot to live music nearby.

Accessibility note: Both restaurants offer outdoor seating and waterside access; request step-free seating when reserving. If tides or weather change, remember the season’s last harvest day is May 1.